It could be one of a number of things or maybe all of them combined but the once self proclaimed ‘Special One’ has surely lost his edge.
Mourinho is a subject that I never get tired of talking about. One of the greatest managers and pantomime villains of all time. When he’s managing in the Premier League I just love to ridicule him but when he’s not there I actually miss him. Of course if he had have managed a Liverpool team to a Premier League title my opinion of him would be very different.
Maybe years of fighting back against the press has finally worn him out. Mourinho always launches a ferocious defence of himself and in the past his players but his tenure at Man Utd has shown a different side to him, often hanging his own players out to dry. This is something the Mourinho of old was not known for and loyalty and unity were key aspects of his previous squads. It was almost like an impenetrable machine charging toward all those league titles in various leagues around Europe.
Are his tactics dated? It’s not easy to understand why his tactics are not appearing to work any more. Maybe with the emergence of many young foreign managers who are coming into the game with fresh ideas and the willingness to take a risk, football is becoming more dynamic across the league and less predictable for managers to know how their opponent is going to play. This could be something Mourinho has failed to adapt to. Sticking with his pragmatic style of sitting back and playing on the counter for a club like Man Utd just doesn’t suit and the fans are getting frustrated as it’s a world away from the swashbuckling football of the Ferguson era.
Are the players not good enough? With the money Mourinho has spent it’s difficult to say this is the problem. There is more than enough talent in that squad to challenge for the league under normal circumstances. With Pep Guardiola’s Man City however these are not normal circumstances and anything less is being highly scrutinised. Of course the players may not be applying themselves correctly to the Mourinho’s style. Sitting back and soaking up pressure is not the same as letting the opposition play and that’s exactly what Utd did against City. There was no pressure from the Utd players the entire game. Even the last 10 minutes when 2-1 down Utd were playing like they were 2-1 up. They desperately needed to get the ball back but instead sat back and allowed City to orchestrate probably the best team goal of the season already to end any chance in this game.
Whether it’s his personality, his tactics or his players it’s still down to him. He needs stop worrying what people think of him and find the strength to re-evaluate his methods and adapt to the modern game. If it’s his players then he needs to get tough on them, they clearly aren’t putting in the effort on the pitch and that’s obvious to see.